On Tuesdays and Thursday, the teacher next door and I do our tutoring together because we do not have a lot of kids. We usually end up doing a Reader's Theatre to help the kids practice their fluency skills. Last Tuesday, Mrs. H and I were discussing about how we both care too much about people we've never met. Me (a blog family who has a very sick baby) and her (Natasha Richardson and her untimely death.) This very special girl (Tina) who I love my time with every week was sitting with us. She asks us what we are talking about, and the other teacher tells her we were having a grown up conversation about people we don't know. Tina then proceeds to tell us "Oh you shouldn't gossip! My pastor at church says if you gossip you will go to hell."
I for one was dumbfounded. That I was just told by a 10 year old that I was going to hell for gossiping? I wanted to explain myself that (1) there is a difference between gossiping and talking about people and (2) we weren't saying anything bad about them in the first place . But I was too annoyed at her comment that I don't believe I said anything at all.
Which brings to the question that I have been pondering. When we told this story to our fellow teachers they were all more horror struck that she was correcting her elders than what she actually said. This is what got me thinking. How old do you have to be before you get to correct people that are older than you? And, how come kids don't get to correct adults? Besides the fact that she was wrong in her assumption that we were gossiping, what if we really were? Would she have to sit there and listen to the adult figures in her life do something she knows is wrong but not be allowed to correct them?
I guess maybe because I am brand new at this adult thing, and still 50% of the people around me are my elders I was curious how this really worked. As I thought about this, I realized that the majority of the time I would not dare to correct my elders and I too was brought up this way. Now, I am not sure what point I was trying to make and think I might be just as confused as I was to begin with.
It's just that kids are told day in and out not to do this and that, and are constantly being corrected and then when they think they've caught their teachers doing something wrong, they aren't allowed to correct them. I guess where Tina went wrong was that what she thought she was "calling" Mrs. H and I out on, we weren't even doing. She might need to go look up the definition of gossiping...
What do you think? Would you be offended if someone younger than you corrected your misbehavior?